Book Review: Babel - R. F. Kuang
This is an astonishing book. On the one hand, it's the basic "Harry Potter" trope - a young orphan is gifted, gets sent to school to learn magic, becomes pals with the other weird kids, has adventures, and fights a monster. Except here, Harry is Chinese, is sent to Oxford University to learn magic, and faces up to the reality of colonialism and Empire.
Oh, and the magic is based on the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis.
I lived in Oxford for several years (although, thankfully, I wasn't a scholar) and Kuang has perfectly captured the madness of the city. Her world-building is delightfully realistic and the parenthetical footnotes sprinkled throughout lead to a mesmerising blurring of reality and fiction. When you read sentences like "Phonological calques are often semantic calques as well." it often feels like you're receiving an education as well as experiencing the narrative flow.
The book's politics aren't subtle - but they needn't be. This isn't smuggled polemic; it is righteous fury bound into a novel and set loose on an unsuspecting world. It is the very essence of what it means to be "woke". Our characters gradually have the scales drop from their eyes and they begin to realise the nightmare world they live in.
A thoroughly entertaining read, with a perfect mixture of alternative history, science-fantasy, heartbreak, and wonder.
On a minor technical note - the publishers have rendered all the Chinese characters as tiny images which makes it hard to read them. A bit of a baffling editorial decision!
Verdict |
---|
- Buy the eBook on Amazon Kindle
- Get the paper book from Hive
- Author's homepage
- Publisher's details
- Borrow from your local library
- ISBN: 9780008501839
Paul Barker said on social.afront.org:
@Edent this really needs to be on my To Be Read list (which lives at https://bookwyrm.social/user/pbarker/books/to-read but needs an update) BookWyrm
Paul Leader says:
@blog Oooh, that sounds brilliant. I love the idea of "outside" perspective on that (frankly rather tired) trope.
And the linguistics side sounds very cool. I like it when magic systems have at least some kind of internal consistency.
Tom Hannen says:
@blog Thanks for this review, that’s the most interesting book I’ve read for a while! (Typesetting was weird though - tiny asterisks in the body text with sensible sized ones in footnotes, or maybe my eyes are going)
More comments on Mastodon.