Book Review: Leviathan Wakes - James S. A. Corey
By @edent
· Book Review Sci Fi The Expanse · 8 comments · 250 words · read ~122 times.
I'm really late to the party on this one! After people singing the praises of the TV show, and my brother recommending them, I finally cracked and read the first book.
It's pretty good! You probably don't need me to tell you that. But, for a book published in 2011, I was surprised at how old-fashioned it felt. It's a bog-standard police procedural. The cop's a drunk with a failed marriage and an obsession with a victim - how many times have we seen that played out? It's also pretty old-school in its choice of characters. There are a couple of female protagonists - but the story is never told from their perspective. Despite the limitless potential offered by off-world sex, everyone seems robustly heterosexual. Compared with something like "The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet" feels almost parochial.
But what elevates it is the way that everything stems from the engineering challenges faced by the inhabitants of various moons and space-stations. There's very little "quantum woo" here - just a fairly linear progression from today. It feels grimy and realistic.
Without getting too far into spoiler territory, I found the various enemies to be - again - tired tropes. Weyland-Yutani casts a long shadow, I guess.
It is enjoyable. But I'm not sure I want to go through all 8 subsequent books. There's lots of innovative sci-fi out there - but this didn't grab my attention.
| Verdict |
|---|
- Buy the eBook on Amazon Kindle
- Get the paper book from Hive
- Author's homepage
- Publisher's details
- Borrow from your local library
- ISBN: 9780748122967
Mastodon
Twitter
Facebook
LinkedIn
Reddit
HackerNews
Lobsters
Pocket
WhatsApp
Telegram
Book Review: Caliban's War - James S. A. Corey
@Edent the later books really don't get any better. it goes from police procedural to sequence of shuttered boxes very quickly. like a very bad RPG session.
@Edent You get chapters from the viewpoints of 2 new female characters in book 2 and there's non hetro-stuff later in the series. Also the evil company you identify isn't the baddie of the whole series - not saying more for spoilers.
@Edent@mastodon the books and show are great. More a saga of the human condition, love, and team solving problems. Plus a bit of police procedural…
I think you might enjoy the TV show more than the book. I saw the first couple of seasons of the TV show, then read this book. I haven’t read any of the other books. I have watched the rest of the TV show, which does not strictly adhere to the books. There’s a significant female protagonist in the show right from the start of the first season who I understand turns up in the books much later. The first season of the TV show has the detective in space on his quest as one of the major plot threads, but by the end of the first season the show is not about that at all. Throughout the show's run there are obvious non-hetrosexual relationships and even polyamory. Unlike Galactic Commons universe, the only scope for diversity is within humanity. And whatever that blue stuff is.
I felt more like the Halo franchise cast a (very) long shadow here, and that shadow was cast by the aspect of that franchise I dislike the most.
That aside, I felt the climax featured a wildly unearned cheat. Had I not been reading a digital copy on my phone, I’d have thrown the book across the room; suffice to say I have not given any other part of this franchise the time of day since that moment.
@Edent I'm just finishing the final book. Overall I really enjoyed it, it goes to a lot of different places. It's fair to say it's quite "safe" in its tropes, but that's one of the reasons I like it (and the TV series). It's like putting on a comfortable pair of slippers and hanging out with good friends.
@jessamyn @Edent
I'd suggest giving it another shot. The series becomes increasingly female-centric as it moves along and there's some remarkable acting. Well, and space battles.
@Edent I love the expanse. I find the reasonably hard scifi elements while maintaining politics, human interaction, etc really work for me. I've done 3 rewatches on the series and I'm most of the way through a second re-listen.
I found the The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet had a love of great space aliens, but the overall setting was just a bit too.. soft scifi for me. It's just a bit too loose and imaginative maybe? (Even if I do love Patricia Rodriguez as a narrator)
More comments on Mastodon.